Pandering to Conspiracy Theorists Won’t Win Votes

Open letter from FACT Aotearoa (Fight Against Conspiracy Theories) to the political parties in the 2023 General Election.

This election year, coordinated disinformation campaigns are spreading false information and conspiracy theories online and at public events.

Tactics include stacking meetings, asking the same pre-prepared questions in multiple forums and media, and attempting to shout down speakers. The aim is to force politicians to respond to and thereby legitimise and amplify fringe views.

The harmful conspiracy theories include claims that the covid vaccine is causing mass deaths and New Zealand will be forced to impose lockdowns by the UN.

The groups promoting these ideas are vocal and radicalised. Some have openly stated their intention to overthrow the government, going as far as calling for the murder or arrest of politicians in a gross parody of the Nuremberg trials. Others have adopted less radical public positions as a strategy to insert disinformation and conspiracy theories into public debate.

It is highly unlikely that people who hold the most extreme conspiracist views will vote for any mainstream political party or candidate. However, we are concerned that candidates will mistake the loud activism of this minority for popular support and feel pressured to pander to them, giving them legitimacy and amplification.

To avoid this we urge candidates to take the following actions:

  • Do not amplify conspiracy theories and disinformation, downplay or change policies to appeal to conspiracy theorists or legitimise unfounded attacks on people or institutions. You will lose more votes than you attract.
  • Inform yourself about the agendas of organisations, influencers and “alternative media” representatives – don’t be naïve. Know the spectrum and draw a line.
  • Demonstrate your commitment to the democratic process by canvassing the full range of views in your electorate to ensure the loud, conspiracy orientated minority don’t drown out other voices.
  • Avoid comments, phrasings and interactions that legitimise or imply you agree with harmful conspiracy theories or disinformation.
  • Maintain your party’s commitment to factual information and evidence-based debate as a basis for policy.

If you want further information, FACT can help. If you have questions about our work or want to know more about the evidence behind our statement, click here or contact info@factaotearoa.nz.

__

Founded during the build-up to the 2020 New Zealand General Election, FACT Aotearoa (Fight Against Conspiracy Theories) is a grassroots charity made up of volunteers from all professions monitoring and actively opposing misinformation in Aotearoa New Zealand.

__

 

Regards,

FACT Aotearoa

Letters & resources

Resource: How to Avoid Media Manipulation Attempts

Resource: How to Avoid Media Manipulation Attempts

Responsible Reporting on False Information. A new resource with tips for how media professionals can minimise narrative hijacking by conspiracy theorists and extremists, and maximise their ability to report on important events. Download now.

Prebunking election misinformation

River of Freedom – Dispatches From the Mirror World

River of Freedom – Dispatches From the Mirror World

A FACT member ventured into the rosy mirror world of the documentary River of Freedom to see what has been airbrushed from the New Zealand Parliament Occupation. The results is a distorted and aggrandised piece of propaganda, removed from the reality we lived through.
Fringe parties and their COVID policy

Fringe parties and their COVID policy

All of the policies demanded by parties seeking the "freedom movement" vote are already government policy, except stopping the vaccine rollout. So why are they calling for that and why do they want an "independent inquiry"?
Why do some parties claim their free speech is under attack?

Why do some parties claim their free speech is under attack?

There's a lot to be said about free speech as an important cornerstone of a free and fair society. But does that mean that all speech is protected? Well, no. Some speech can incite harm on our community. Find out why conspiracy theorists are using this topic as a policy platform.
Minor parties policies target imaginary “globalist” plots. WHY?

Minor parties policies target imaginary “globalist” plots. WHY?

Strange isn't it, that conspiracy theorist parties this election all have policies about reviewing or leaving international bodies like the UN, WEF and WHO. It's a tale as old as time, misinterpreting non-binding agreements as sinister "globalist" plots to control you. Let's dive in to the origins of these unfounded fears.
Why conspiracy theorists are obsessed with the Bill of Rights Act

Why conspiracy theorists are obsessed with the Bill of Rights Act

The government was careful to maintain the rule of law during the pandemic. It allowed itself to be challenged in court, and accepted rulings against it. That seems like the opposite of tyranny. But the conspiracists belief that they are fighting “tyranny” is one of the reasons you’re hearing so much about NZBORA.
Our politicians are selected

Our politicians are selected

NZ politicians are selected by their party and elected by us, not by a global cabal of "them". Quite simple really, but gird your loins for a long explanation of this conspiratorial thought-terminating cliche and why it's nearly impossible for it to be true.
FALSE CLAIM: “They” manipulate the count

FALSE CLAIM: “They” manipulate the count

We count votes by hand in this country, and we count them carefully… but it seems like not everybody knows that. And it’s normal for the final result to change after election night, but not everyone gets that either.